Case Study

35028 Clan Line. Heritage Steam Railway Steam Locomotive Tender Water Tank Corroded Problems

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.

The Client

35028 Clan Line
Merchant Navy Locomotive Preservation Society (MNLPS)
Battersea, London

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.

Tender Water Tank Corroded and pitied corrosion

Clan Line chief mechanical engineer wanted to restore and preserve the original tender, if at all possible, and avoid having a to have a new tank built.

They were looking for a solution that would provide the following:

  • Provide long term anti-corrosion protection.
  • To be flexible within the tender’s water tank moving at 70 mph.
  • Build up wall thickness to compensate for steel loss due to corrosive activity within the tank.
  • Restore and preserve the existing original tender.
  • Extend the working life of the tender by 25 – 30 years.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.


Challenges

All works were planned were to be completed within a single site visit of four weeks during the January maintenance shutdown.

The tank is made from carbon steel and is of a horizontal irregular shaped rectangular design and is fitted with a complex structure latticework baffles and bracings.

The water within the tank contains chemical water treatment additive/s.

All sections of the tank exhibited considerable corrosion, steel loss and deep cratering, especially in the lower 18” of the water tank side walls.

It was required to carry out surface preparation to remove the remaining failed lining, corrosion and to install a long-lasting anti-corrosion tank lining treatment.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.


The lining treatment applied had to have high anti-corrosion properties, improve strength of steel in areas of steel loss due to corrosive activity, be sufficiently flexible for a water tank moving at 70 mph and to be chemically resistant to the water treatment additives used.

Access to the tank was limited to two small hatches located on the roof at the rear of the tender.

Movement within and around the tank would be difficult because of the complex array of steel braces and stiffeners in the tank that afforded only narrow openings for movement.

During our work maintenance work on several Pullman coaches would be carried out (roof painting, changing wheels etc) in the same shed and close to where we would be working. 

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.


Solution

The surface preparation would be carried out by means of abrasive grit blasting.

The progress on this was slow because there are a great many surfaces to prepare. It was also important to maintain the quality of the blast and to avoid rust reforming on the clean prepared steel during the 3 weeks that it took to blast the tank.

Although the internal surfaces were very badly corroded indeed and there was a great deal of deep pitting, we did not found anything that we were not expecting and the tender was completely suitable for our restoration system.

After removing the spent abrasive, cleaned the tank by brush and vacuum ready for application of our tank lining and repair system.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatmentSpecialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment
Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatmentSpecialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment
 

Our water tank lining system comprises of several different resin layers, including a strong anti-corrosion coat followed by several coats of an impervious 2 pack, glass flake reinforced epoxy resin-based water tank lining material.

This system had been especially developed for the in-situ treatment of heavily corroded water tanks that may have been leaking and would ordinarily have had to be replaced.

Our lining system is a cost-effective method to extend the working life of an existing tank for many years and avoids the expensive of replacement and down-time.


Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.


The work was finished in a light grey colour.

For commercial reasons we are unable to show or detail all the different stages of the process, materials and technologies involved.

It may be worth mentioning here that we have not yet found a tank that we have been unable to repair and so far, we have never had a leak with our tank lining and repair system installed.


The Results

This was certainly amongst one of the most interesting tanks that we have worked on and certainly one of the most complex internal structures that we have worked on.

Our strong, yet flexible, anti-corrosion tank lining system will extend the working life of this tank and the tender for many years to come.

Our work on the tank was completed on time and on budget which avoided the expense, inconvenience and delays of replacing the original tank and having a new tank built.

With suitable care this tank should, now last another 30 plus years.

Restoration and Preservation of the existing original – not replacement
We strongly believe that it is better to, were at all possible, to keep the original historical heritage asset with restoration and preservation, rather than replacing with a new one without any history, character or soul.

Clan Line Tender Water Tank – Before and After Restoration & Preservation Treatment

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.


For more information about this wonderful historic steam locomotive, follow this link: https://clan-line.org.uk.

From the Clan Line website news section: https://clan-line.org.uk/news/slane_4/.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Limited have been working very hard on the inside of our tender tank, giving it at least another thirty years of active life (more than most of us will have!) They have grit-blasted the interior, including all the bracing struts and baffles, and meticulously applied several coats of epoxy resin. You can see more detail on their own website, www.specialist-coatings.co.uk, and their Facebook page here.

We are now preparing for our first steam test, followed by the boiler inspector's "hot exam".

And also here: https://clan-line.org.uk/news/slane_5/.

The Tender Work Is Complete

14th February 2019

Specialist Coatings (GB) Limited have completed their work treating the inside of our tender tank to give it at least another thirty years of life. Even though most people most people will never see all this work, the results are still very important to the preservation of the locomotive. The difference in the internal appearance is quite spectacular.

Videos of Clan Line 35028: Best to turn the sound up on your PC or device.

Clan Line Torbay Express: Click Here
Running at speed: Click Here
Clan Line racing through Gillingham Dorset at speed: Click Here
35028 Clan Line at the Depot #1: Click Here
35028 Clan Line at the Depot #2: Click Here
Project 28: UK Heritage Hub's Clan Line Farewell: Click Here

Videos courtesy of Clan Line, OVP (Oldham Video Productions) and Others

It was a pleasure working on such an important engine. We were made very welcome by the team of dedicated engines who help look after her.

This special anti-corrosion lining system can be used to restore the water tanks on all heritage railway steam locomotives and for bulk water storage tanks, bolted sectional Braithwaite tanks etc..

If you have project that you are currently working on or considering in the future and would like general advice on long term corrosion prevention treatments, please contact us.

If you belong to a heritage steam railway association or know someone who does and feel this could be benefit to someone, please feel to share it or contact us.

Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.Specialist Coatings (GB) Ltd: 35028 Clan Line tender water Tank restoration and preservation anti-corrosion treatment.